L&O: The only way to get him back from Israel is prove he's Irish

Law & Order S11 E5 “Return”

“You want us goyim to do what? Oy vey!”

“You want us goyim to do what? Oy vey!”

Detectives learn a Jewish man paid to have his father's business partner killed, but when Briscoe and Green go to arrest him they learn he's fled to Israel. The Law of Return protects him from extradition, so Carmichael pleads her case in Rabbinical court in an effort to prove he's actually Irish. A shonda!

We're not completely comfortable with Law & Order season 11 episode 5 "Return." Our guest is Michal Schick of the Nice Jewish Fangirls podcast.

This episode is based on the ripped-from-the-headlines case of Samuel Sheinbein.